When choosing an ecommerce platform, merchants often focus on monthly fees and feature lists. Yet for a growing brand, the most important pricing question is not what a platform costs today, but how its costs evolve as your sales increase. The fundamental difference between BigCommerce and Shopify lies in this scaling model, creating a critical decision point for any ambitious store.
BigCommerce ties its plans to your store's annual sales volume, automatically upgrading you to more expensive plans when you pass certain thresholds. Shopify, in contrast, lets you choose your plan based on the features you need, with no forced upgrades based on revenue. This article breaks down the two models to clarify which platform offers a more predictable path for growth in 2026.
What are BigCommerce's annual sales thresholds that trigger automatic plan upgrades?
BigCommerce automatically upgrades your plan based on your trailing 12-month sales volume. The Core plan (formerly Standard) has a threshold of $30,000 in annual sales. The Growth plan (formerly Plus) has a threshold of $100,000. Exceeding these limits results in an automatic, mandatory move to the next, more expensive plan tier.
These thresholds were lowered in June 2026, meaning stores now hit the upgrade trigger sooner. For example, a store with $40,000 in annual sales that previously fit on the Standard plan (with its $50,000 cap) is now forced onto the more expensive Growth plan. This structure means your platform costs can jump significantly, not because you need new features, but simply because you became more successful.
A critical detail is that these sales thresholds include more than just product revenue. BigCommerce counts the gross order value, including taxes and shipping fees, toward your annual limit. A store selling $28,000 in products could easily cross the $30,000 Core threshold based on shipping and tax alone, triggering an unexpected plan upgrade. This makes forecasting your platform costs even more complex.
For the Scale plan, which starts after the Growth tier, the model changes slightly. It has a monthly sales cap, and exceeding it incurs a 0.9% overage fee on the additional revenue, before eventually triggering a move to the enterprise-level Performance plan at $2 million in annual sales.
How does Shopify's pricing structure differ for high-volume merchants?
Shopify's pricing structure is not based on sales volume caps for its main plans (Basic, Shopify, and Advanced). Merchants select a plan based on the features they require, such as the number of staff accounts, reporting capabilities, and international selling tools. You can remain on the Basic plan regardless of how high your sales grow, though it's often financially wise to upgrade.
As sales volume increases, upgrading to a higher Shopify plan becomes beneficial due to lower credit card processing rates and reduced third-party transaction fees. For a store on annual billing using Shopify Payments, the break-even point to move from Basic to the Shopify (now called Grow) plan is around $25,000 in monthly revenue. At that point, the savings from the lower transaction rate cover the higher monthly plan fee.
This creates a clear trade-off: control versus automation. Shopify gives you full control over when to upgrade, but you must do the math to know when it makes sense. BigCommerce automates the decision, but you lose control and face sudden price hikes. The decision to upgrade on Shopify is driven by a cost-benefit analysis a merchant controls, not by a mandatory platform rule. This provides a more predictable cost structure.
For the largest businesses, Shopify Plus offers a dedicated enterprise solution starting around $2,300 per month. This plan is for merchants with very high volume who need advanced features like customizable checkout, dedicated support, and extensive API access. The move to Shopify Plus is a deliberate choice, often when monthly sales approach $800,000, not an automatic consequence of passing a sales threshold on a lower plan.
What is the cost difference at 1,000, 5,000, and 10,000 orders per month?
A direct cost comparison depends heavily on your Average Order Value (AOV), as BigCommerce's limits are based on revenue, not order count. However, we can create a comparison table based on assumed revenue that corresponds to typical order volumes. This table illustrates how the two platforms compare on plan fees and transaction fees, using annual billing for base costs.
Worked Example: A Store Hitting $120,000 in Annual Revenue
Consider a store hitting $120,000 in annual revenue for the first time. On BigCommerce, this store has just crossed the $100,000 threshold for the Growth plan. The platform will automatically upgrade the store to the Scale plan. The monthly fee immediately jumps from $79 to $299, an increase of $220 per month or $2,640 per year. This happens regardless of whether the merchant needs any features from the Scale plan.
Now, let's look at the same store on Shopify. At $120,000 annually, or $10,000 per month, the merchant is likely on the Basic plan ($29/mo). They can choose to upgrade to the Shopify plan ($79/mo) to get better credit card rates. The rate drops from 2.9% to 2.7% (using Shopify Payments), a saving of 0.2%. On $10,000 of monthly sales, this saves $20. The $50 increase in the plan fee is not yet covered by the savings.
The Shopify merchant can wait until their monthly sales reach the break-even point of around $25,000 before upgrading. They have the control to make the switch when it benefits their bottom line. The BigCommerce merchant has no choice. Their platform cost nearly quadruples overnight, reducing the cash available for reinvestment in inventory, marketing, or other growth initiatives.
| Metric | Shopify | BigCommerce |
|---|---|---|
| Base Plan (Low Volume) | Basic: $29/mo (annual) | Core: $29/mo (annual) |
| Mid-Tier Plan | Shopify: $79/mo (annual) | Growth: $79/mo (annual) |
| Forced Upgrade Trigger | None based on sales volume. | Yes, at $30K and $100K in trailing 12-month sales. |
| Third-Party Transaction Fee | 2% on Basic, 1% on Shopify, 0.6% on Advanced (waived with Shopify Payments). | 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, 0.6% on Scale (waived with embedded providers). |
| Predictability | High. Costs scale with features used and transaction rates. | Lower. Sudden cost jumps when sales thresholds are crossed. |
For a store doing $120,000 in annual revenue (roughly 1,000 orders at $10 AOV, or 250 orders at $40 AOV), the difference is stark. On Shopify, you could be on the $79/month plan. On BigCommerce, that revenue forces you from the $79/month Growth plan to the $299/month Scale plan.
Are there feature differences between BigCommerce and Shopify plans at similar price points?
Yes, the platforms have different philosophies on what to include. BigCommerce has historically promoted its extensive list of built-in features, even on lower-tier plans. This includes things like product reviews and real-time shipping quotes, which may require a third-party app on Shopify.
This presents a classic "All-in-One vs. Best-in-Breed" trade-off. BigCommerce offers a simpler, all-in-one package that can be easier to manage initially. However, you are limited to the quality and functionality of its built-in tools. If a native feature is merely average, you have little recourse.
This highlights the hidden cost of bundled features. A "free" built-in tool is only valuable if it meets your needs. If your brand outgrows BigCommerce's native reviews and you install a specialized app like Yotpo, you are now paying twice. You pay for the third-party app, and you continue to pay for the bundled feature you no longer use, as its cost is baked into your mandatory plan fee.
Shopify's approach relies on a leaner core platform supplemented by a vast app ecosystem of over 10,000 applications. This allows merchants to build a more customized tech stack, paying only for the specific functionality they need. While this can lead to additional app subscription costs, it also offers greater flexibility and choice. You can select the best possible app for every job, from email marketing to loyalty programs.
For businesses with complex product catalogs, such as those with many variants, BigCommerce's native support for up to 600 variants per product is a significant advantage over Shopify's standard limits. An edge case where BigCommerce might be preferable is a B2B store selling industrial parts where a single product might have hundreds of size, material, and finish combinations. Here, the built-in variant capacity could outweigh the downside of forced plan upgrades.
However, for most direct-to-consumer brands, Shopify's ease of use and the breadth of its app store often outweigh the benefits of BigCommerce's built-in features. The ability to find a specialized tool for nearly any business problem provides a long-term competitive advantage that a fixed feature set cannot match.
How does each platform handle transaction fees as sales volume increases?
Both platforms have similar-looking transaction fee structures, but they apply in different scenarios. Shopify charges a transaction fee (from 2% on Basic down to 0.2% on Plus) only if you use a third-party payment gateway instead of their native Shopify Payments. If you use Shopify Payments, this fee is waived completely.
Following a June 2026 update, BigCommerce introduced an "Open Payment Provider Fee" that mirrors Shopify's model. If you use a payment processor outside of their curated list of "embedded providers" (like Stripe or PayPal), you will pay a fee of 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, or 0.6% on Scale. This change eliminated a key historical differentiator where BigCommerce claimed zero transaction fees on all plans.
The concrete step for any merchant considering BigCommerce is to check if their preferred payment gateway is on the "embedded" list before committing. If it is not, you must factor in this additional fee, which can be substantial. For a store on the Growth plan doing $100,000 per year through a non-embedded provider, this fee adds an extra $1,000 to your annual costs.
For a growing business, the key is whether your preferred payment provider is on BigCommerce's short embedded list or if you can use Shopify Payments. If not, both platforms will charge a similar percentage on top of your processor's own rates, making the cost largely equivalent.
Which platform offers more predictable costs for a rapidly growing business?
Shopify generally offers more predictable costs for a rapidly growing business. Its structure allows costs to scale smoothly. As your revenue increases, your processing fees become a larger part of your expenses, but your base platform fee only changes when you choose to upgrade to access better rates or more features. There are no sudden four-fold increases in your monthly bill because you had a good sales month.
BigCommerce's model of forced upgrades based on revenue introduces significant cost uncertainty. A business owner can see their monthly platform fee triple overnight simply for crossing an arbitrary sales threshold set by the platform, not by their own need for new features. This can make financial planning and budgeting more difficult for a scaling brand.
That sudden increase has a real opportunity cost. The extra $2,640 per year paid by a BigCommerce store forced onto the Scale plan could have funded a small pay-per-click campaign, purchased new inventory for a product launch, or paid for a professional theme. Instead, that capital goes directly to the platform as a tax on growth.
What do merchants on Reddit and community forums say about scaling on each platform?
Merchant discussions frequently highlight the frustration with BigCommerce's forced upgrades. Many long-term users have expressed disappointment after being moved to a more expensive plan due to the lowered sales thresholds, without receiving any additional value for the increased cost. The sentiment is often that the platform is punishing them for their own success.
This introduces a level of "platform risk" that is a recurring theme in merchant communities. Business owners feel that the rules were changed on them, moving the goalposts on pricing after they had already invested time and money into building their store on the platform. This can erode the trust between the merchant and the platform provider.
In contrast, discussions around scaling on Shopify more often focus on managing app costs or deciding the right moment to upgrade to Shopify Plus. The conversations are about strategic choices within the merchant's control. While no platform is without complaints, the nature of the complaints is different. Shopify users discuss optimizing a predictable system, while some BigCommerce users feel trapped by an unpredictable one.
How can Shopify merchants use apps to manage the costs of high order volume?
As order volume grows on Shopify, operational efficiency becomes as important as marketing. Higher order counts can lead to increased shipping costs and customer service inquiries. One specific area where costs can accumulate is with repeat customers who place multiple separate orders before the first one has shipped, resulting in redundant shipping fees and packaging materials.
Your platform choice shouldn't punish you for growth. The right structure allows your costs to scale predictably, so you can reinvest in your business, not just pay a higher platform tax.
This is where apps that streamline fulfillment operations become crucial. An order merging tool addresses this directly by allowing your team to combine multiple paid orders from the same customer into a single shipment. Merchants can merge orders by hand for one-off situations or switch on automatic merging to handle this at scale, based on rules they define to reduce shipping costs and simplify the packing process.
The savings can be substantial. For a store with 5,000 orders per month, if just 5% of those are repeat orders that can be merged, that's 250 shipments. If merging saves an average of $5 in postage and materials per shipment, the store saves $1,250 per month, or $15,000 per year. This is a direct boost to the bottom line, achieved by improving operational workflow.
By managing the operational side of high order volume, Shopify merchants can protect their margins even as they scale. Tacey provides tools to help manage these complexities. With features for both manual and automatic order merging, you can reduce redundant shipping costs and improve fulfillment efficiency. Instead of watching profits get eaten by operational overhead, you can ensure that growth translates directly to a healthier bottom line. You can learn more about order merging or install Tacey from the Shopify App Store to get started.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if I exceed my BigCommerce sales limit?
If your trailing 12-month sales exceed the threshold for the Core or Growth plan, BigCommerce will automatically upgrade you to the next, more expensive plan on your next billing cycle. You cannot choose to remain on the lower-cost plan.
Does Shopify ever force a plan upgrade?
No, Shopify does not force you to upgrade your plan based on sales volume. You can stay on any plan regardless of your revenue, though it often becomes more cost-effective to upgrade to a higher plan as you grow to take advantage of lower transaction fees.
Are credit card processing fees included in the platform fees?
No, for both platforms, credit card processing fees are separate. These fees are paid directly to the payment processor (like Shopify Payments, Stripe, or PayPal) and are typically a percentage plus a fixed fee per transaction (e.g., 2.9% + 30¢).
Which platform is better for B2B (business-to-business) sales?
Historically, BigCommerce has been considered stronger for B2B out of the box due to built-in features like customer groups and purchase orders. However, Shopify has significantly invested in its B2B capabilities, making them available on all plans since 2026, with advanced features on Shopify Plus.
Can I avoid BigCommerce's 'Open Payment Provider Fee'?
Yes, you can avoid this fee by using one of the payment providers on BigCommerce's "embedded" list, which includes major players like Stripe and PayPal. If you use a processor not on this list, the fee will apply.




