Blog/Marketing & Growth

Migrating from Squarespace to Shopify: A 2026 Checklist and Cost Guide

Considering a move from Squarespace to Shopify? This guide provides a complete checklist, cost breakdown, and step-by-step process for a successful migration in 2026.

Odera Joseph Echendu, Founder, TaceyOdera Joseph EchenduFounder, Tacey · 19 November 2026 · 12 min read · Last updated 21 November 2026
Tacey blog cover: the headline "Migrating from Squarespace to Shopify: A 2026 Checklist and Cost Guide" in white on a dark background

If your store is growing, you may be hitting the operational limits of Squarespace and eyeing Shopify's commerce-focused toolset. A platform migration can feel daunting, but with a clear plan, it's a manageable process that unlocks significant potential for growth. This guide provides a step-by-step checklist for moving from Squarespace to Shopify in 2026.

When should a growing store migrate from Squarespace to Shopify?

The time to migrate is when Squarespace's limitations start costing you sales or operational efficiency. This often happens when you need more advanced inventory management, deeper app integrations for things like loyalty or subscriptions, or more control over your checkout process to improve conversion rates.

The cost of delaying migration can be measured in lost revenue. For instance, if your checkout lacks popular payment options like Shop Pay or local payment methods, you could be losing sales. A five percent increase in conversion rate on a store earning $20,000 per month is an extra $1,000 in revenue you are currently leaving on the table.

Squarespace is excellent for content-first sites with simple commerce needs. However, as your product catalog or order volume grows, you'll feel the friction. Shopify is built commerce-first, which becomes evident in its robust inventory tools, extensive app ecosystem, and features designed to handle higher sales volume.

A key technical trigger is product complexity. While Squarespace allows more variants per product (up to 250) than Shopify's 100-variant limit, Shopify's broader ecosystem is better designed for managing large, complex catalogs. If you need multi-location inventory, advanced bundling, or integrations that manage product data, Shopify’s commerce-centric foundation offers a more scalable solution despite the per-product variant cap.

What is the step-by-step process for migrating products and customers?

The migration process centers on exporting data from Squarespace via CSV files and importing it into Shopify. While products and customers can be moved this way, historical orders and other content types often require more manual work or specialized apps.

Here is the general process for your core data:

  1. Export Products from Squarespace: In your Squarespace admin, navigate to Commerce > Inventory and click "Export All" to download a CSV of your product data. This file will include names, SKUs, prices, and descriptions.
  2. Reformat the Product CSV for Shopify: Download Shopify’s sample product CSV file from the Products > Import screen. You must map the columns from your Squarespace export to Shopify's required format. This is often the most time-consuming manual step.
  3. Import Products into Shopify: In the Shopify admin, go to Products > Import and upload your newly formatted CSV file. It's wise to do this with the "Publish new products to all sales channels" option unticked so you can review everything before it goes live.
  4. Export and Import Customers: In Squarespace, go to Contacts and export your customer list. Like the product data, you'll need to reformat this file to match Shopify's customer CSV template before importing it under the Customers section in your Shopify admin. Note that customer passwords cannot be transferred.

A Closer Look: The CSV Reformatting Step

This is where most DIY migrations run into trouble. You must open both the Squarespace export and the Shopify template in a spreadsheet program. You will then copy and paste columns from one file to the other, ensuring the headers match Shopify’s format exactly. For example, a Squarespace column named "Price" might need to be mapped to Shopify's "Variant Price" column.

A major "gotcha" is product imagery. Your Squarespace CSV export contains image file names, but not the images themselves. For Shopify's importer to work, the image URLs must be publicly accessible online. This means you must keep your Squarespace site live during the import so Shopify can crawl and copy the images from their original URLs.

After importing customers, you must prompt them to create new passwords. You cannot do this for them. A best practice is to use a bulk invitation app from the Shopify App Store, like Bulk Account Inviter. This sends an email to your imported customers asking them to activate their account on your new store, which guides them through setting a new password.

How do you redirect URLs from Squarespace to Shopify to preserve SEO?

Preserving your SEO requires creating a 301 redirect map. This tells search engines that your pages have permanently moved, passing along their ranking authority. You must map every old Squarespace URL to its new Shopify equivalent and upload these redirects before pointing your domain to the new site.

This step is critical because URL structures change between the platforms. For example, a Squarespace product page might be `/shop/p/product-name`, while on Shopify it becomes `/products/product-name`. Skipping redirects will result in 404 errors for customers and a significant drop in search engine rankings. [1]

A complete redirect map requires a full list of your current URLs. The best way to get this is with a site crawler tool like Screaming Frog. Run a crawl on your live Squarespace site to generate a spreadsheet of every indexable URL. This file becomes the foundation of your redirect map, ensuring you do not miss any pages.

The cost of a failed redirect strategy can be catastrophic for an established brand. A poorly executed migration can cause an immediate and lasting drop in organic traffic, with losses of 30% or more being common. [1] This can take months to recover from, making the meticulous work of mapping URLs one of the highest-return activities in the entire project.

To implement redirects, go to Online Store > Navigation in your Shopify admin and select "URL Redirects". You can add them one by one or upload a CSV for bulk changes. The process involves crawling your live Squarespace site to get a full list of URLs, mapping them to the new Shopify URLs in a spreadsheet, and then importing that file into Shopify.

What are the estimated costs involved in a Squarespace to Shopify migration?

The cost of migrating includes your monthly Shopify plan, a new theme, and potentially fees for migration apps or an agency. A do-it-yourself migration can be low-cost, while a full agency-led project can range from a few thousand to tens of thousands of dollars.

Here's a breakdown of potential costs:

  • Shopify Plan: Plans for a full online store start with Basic at $29/month (billed annually) and go up to Advanced at $299/month (billed annually). The Grow plan is a common choice for expanding stores at $79/month annually. [2]
  • Squarespace Plan: For comparison, Squarespace plans with full e-commerce features range from about $16/month to $99/month on annual billing, though transaction fees can apply on lower tiers.
  • Migration Apps: Apps to help with migrating order history or complex data can range from free to install with usage fees, to one-time charges like $39 for a blog import tool. [3]
  • Agency Fees: Professional migration services can start around $1,250 for small catalogs and increase significantly based on complexity, with some full-service migrations costing $8,000 or more.

Worked Example: A Sample Migration Budget

Consider a store with 200 products and 2,000 past orders. A DIY migration might cost around $550 for the first three months. This includes a Shopify Grow plan ($79/mo), a paid theme ($250 one-time), and an order import app like EZ Importer, which could cost around $60 to import the 2,000 orders. This budget assumes you do all the labor yourself.

For the same store, a basic agency-led migration would start around $2,500. This covers product, customer, and order migration, theme setup, and redirect implementation. This fee frees you from the technical work but does not include custom design or development, which would increase the cost significantly. It is a trade-off between your time and your money.

Remember to budget for recurring app costs. If you used Squarespace Extensions for subscriptions or loyalty, you must find and pay for Shopify app equivalents. These new subscriptions are a hidden cost of migration. A typical store might spend $50 to $150 per month on essential apps for reviews, email marketing, and customer service functionality.

Finally, consider the opportunity cost of your own time. A DIY migration can take 40-80 hours of focused work. If your time is better spent on marketing, product development, or customer service, paying an expert to handle the technical details can provide a strong return on investment by getting your new, more powerful store to market faster.

A platform move is a chance to rebuild for growth, not just copy what you had. Focus on what your store needs for the next two years, not just what it had yesterday.

Odera Joseph Echendu, Founder, Tacey

Which data can be migrated automatically versus manually?

Products and customers can generally be moved via CSV files, but most other content requires manual rebuilding or specialized apps. Order history, blog posts, and site pages are the most common items that do not transfer cleanly with Squarespace's native export tools.

Order history is particularly difficult because the data structures are completely different. Shopify tracks customers, orders, and products with unique IDs that must be linked correctly. A simple CSV import cannot create these relationships, which is why a specialized app is needed to process the raw data from Squarespace and re-create each order with its associated line items and customer record.

Migrating product reviews is almost always a manual task. You must first find a Shopify reviews app you like, such as Judge.me or Loox. Then, you need to copy your reviews from your Squarespace site and paste them into a spreadsheet. This spreadsheet must be formatted precisely according to the template provided by your new reviews app before you can import it.

This table outlines what to expect for different data types:

Data Type Migration Method Notes
Products (Physical/Service) CSV Export/Import Squarespace exports up to 10,000 products, but the file excludes featured images, variant images, and alt text.
Customers CSV Export/Import Customer passwords cannot be migrated. Plan to have customers reset their passwords.
Order History App or Manual Squarespace's order export doesn't map cleanly to Shopify. Using an app like EZ Importer is recommended. [3]
Blog Posts & Pages XML Export + App or Manual Squarespace exports blog content to a WordPress-format XML file, but this often requires an app or manual copy-pasting to move into Shopify.
Reviews Manual Squarespace has no native review export. You must use a third-party Shopify app like Judge.me or Loox to import a CSV of reviews you create yourself.
Gift Cards & Subscriptions Manual Balances and recurring subscriptions must be recreated by hand in Shopify.

What are the most common challenges during the migration process?

The most frequent challenges are data mismatches from CSV files, preserving SEO through redirects, and recreating the design and functionality of the old site. Underestimating the manual work involved, especially for content pages and order history, is a common pitfall.

An edge case that breaks the standard process is having non-unique SKUs in Squarespace. Shopify requires every product variant to have a unique SKU for its inventory system to function correctly. If you have duplicate SKUs, the product import will fail. You must first perform a data cleanup exercise in your spreadsheet to identify and assign unique SKUs to all variants.

Product data often requires significant cleanup. For instance, if a Squarespace product has more than three options (e.g., style, color, size, material), it must be reconfigured to fit Shopify's three-option limit. This often means creating multiple new products in Shopify from the one complex product in Squarespace, or using a specialized app to handle the extra options.

Failing to implement a comprehensive 301 redirect strategy is the single biggest risk to your search traffic. Every URL changes during the migration, and if you don't tell search engines where the new pages are, your rankings will suffer. [1]

How do you choose a new Shopify theme that matches your old brand?

Start by looking for a Shopify theme that reflects your brand's aesthetic, but prioritize mobile performance and features built for conversion. While you can't transfer your Squarespace design, the migration is an opportunity to adopt a theme optimized specifically for e-commerce.

Shopify's Theme Store offers a wide range of free and paid options. Filter themes by industry, catalog size, and features like quick-buy or sticky headers. Look at the theme demos on a mobile device, as a significant portion of your traffic will likely come from phones.

Here you will face a key trade-off: feature-rich versus lightweight themes. A theme with many built-in features like a mega-menu, pop-ups, and advanced filtering can save you money on apps. However, these themes can sometimes be slower to load. A minimal, lightweight theme will be faster but will require you to add more apps to achieve the same level of functionality.

To make the right choice, perform a functionality audit of your existing Squarespace site. Make a list of every feature you rely on, from image galleries and lookbooks to announcement bars and specific button styles. Then, evaluate Shopify themes based on which of these features are included versus which you would need to add with an app. This clarifies the true cost and performance implications of each option.

Don't aim for a pixel-perfect copy of your old site. Instead, use this as a chance to improve user experience. Focus on clear navigation, high-quality product imagery, and a streamlined path to checkout. Many brands find their site design and conversion rates improve after moving to a purpose-built Shopify theme.

What post-migration actions are crucial for immediate growth on Shopify?

Once your store is live on Shopify, the first priority is to leverage the platform's powerful tools to increase profitability. A key action is to implement post-purchase upsells and offers directly on the order status page to increase your average order value (AOV) from day one.

This post-checkout moment is a powerful opportunity that is largely inaccessible on Squarespace. On Shopify, however, you have full control over the order status page. This is valuable real estate where you can engage with a customer who has just demonstrated maximum purchase intent. They have already trusted you with their payment details, making them receptive to relevant follow-up offers.

This is where your new, more flexible platform shines. After a customer completes their payment, you have a unique opportunity to present them with relevant offers when they are highly engaged. This can include one-click product recommendations or the chance to add a free gift to their just-placed order.

Using an app like Tacey, you can add these capabilities to your order status page instantly. The "Recommended for you" and "Free gift" tools are designed to boost AOV without interrupting the original checkout flow. It's a simple, effective way to capitalize on your new platform's power immediately. Explore how to add a free gift and Recommended for you row and install Tacey to get started.

Frequently asked questions

Will my website have downtime during the migration?

No, a properly managed migration involves no downtime. You build your new Shopify store in the background while your Squarespace site remains live. You only switch your domain's DNS settings to point to Shopify after the new site is fully built and tested.

Can I keep my domain name when moving to Shopify?

Yes, you can transfer your domain from Squarespace to Shopify or simply update your DNS records to point your existing domain to your new Shopify store. Be aware that Squarespace may lock a domain for 60 days after registration or transfer, which could affect your timeline.

Do my customer passwords migrate to Shopify?

No, for security reasons, customer passwords can never be migrated between platforms. When you import your customer list, they will need to create a new password the first time they log in to your Shopify store. It's a good practice to communicate this to them on launch day.

What happens to my Squarespace subscription?

You should keep your Squarespace subscription active for at least a couple of weeks after your Shopify store goes live. This ensures you can access any data you might have missed and that all image links in exported content continue to work until you've moved them to Shopify's servers.

Does Shopify's migration app work for Squarespace?

No, Shopify’s native Store Migration app does not support Squarespace directly. You must rely on CSV file imports, which may require significant manual reformatting, or use a third-party migration app from the Shopify App Store.

Odera Joseph Echendu, Founder, Tacey
WRITTEN BYOdera Joseph EchenduFounder, TaceyOdera builds Tacey, post-purchase order editing for Shopify stores. He writes about what actually happens between the moment a customer pays and the moment a warehouse picks the order.More from Odera →